Revisiting responsibilities and violence through religious agents, in South Africa and the Basque Country.
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5902/2236672538083Keywords:
restitution, religious activists, new violence, subjects implicated, post-apartheid, Basque peace process.Abstract
This text deals with new and uncomfortable aspects that stress processes of internal violence management and national reconstruction. Specifically, I analyze activities mobilized by religious agents who interpellate these efforts to show other figures of responsibility and suffering that are normally minimized by placing all eyes and devices on the essentialized victim-victimizer pair. I discuss this from examples from two different contexts: the South African post apartheid and the Basque peace process (Spain). The ethnographic material addresses the diverse effects and facets involved in the demands for "restitution" mobilized by the South African entity Restitution Center, which, without abandoning the category of reconciliation that dominated the TRC, aims to raise awareness among the white community about their debt, their responsibility during apartheid. The second is an ethnographic record of an event mobilized by the diocese of Bilbao (Basque Country) "Bake topaketa, Encounter for Peace", which aims to raise awareness among the population in general about cases of lesser-known victims, who in turn have relationship with ETA victimizers (ETA organization). It is interesting to think about the complexity of dimensions that encompass processes of internal violence, which as the years go by show new facets and new protagonists. The religious dimension here operates as a driving force for other movements, through religious activist specialists, with their specific rhetoric and resources.Downloads
References
ARENDT, H. Responsabilidad colectiva. In: ARENDT, H Responsabilidad y juicio. Barcelona: Paidós, 2007. p.xvii-xxiv
CABANILLAS N. Prodigal Daughters. Stories of South African Women in Exile. Cadernos Pagu, Campinas, vol. 42, janeiro-junho, pp. 523-530, 2014.
CASTILLEJO, A. On the question of historical injuries. Transitional justice, anthropology and the vicissitudes of listening. Anthropology Today, vol. 29, nº.1, pp, 17-20, 2013
CATOGGIO, M. S. Política contra el Estado autoritario, religión y derechos humanos. La impronta regional de un activismo trasnacional. Papeles de Trabajo, vol.10, nº. 17, pp. 184-20, 2016.
DIDIER F. On Resentment and Ressentiment The Politics and Ethics of Moral Emotions Source. Current Anthropology, vol. 54, nº. 3. pp. 249-267, 2013.
GATTI, G. Un Mundo de víctimas. Anthropos: Barcelona. 2017.
GRUENBAUM, H. The Time after the War: Notes on Historical Encounters Erasures and Post-apartheid Pasts. International Journal on Culture and Society, vol. 5, pp. 185-196, 2012.
HINTON, A. Transitional Justice: Global Mechanisms Local Realities after Genocide and Mass Violence. New Brunswick: Routgers University Press, 2010.
INGOLD, T.; JO L.V. Ways of walking : ethnography and practice on foot. University of Aberdeen: UK. 2008.
IRAZUZTA, I; RODRÍGUEZ M.S; VILLALÓN, A.M. Victims as Educators': Sentimental Education in a Peace-Building Context. Journal of Human Rights Practice, vol. 9, nº. 1, pp. 50-67, 2017.
MAMDANI, M. Amnesty or impunity? A preliminary critique of the Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa (TRC). Diacritics, vol. 32, nº.3, pp. 33-59, 2002
PINEAU, Marisa & FLORES, Celina. Arrepentimiento? ¿Justificación? ¿Voces perdidas? Luces y sombras de los testimonios de los perpetradores en la Sudáfrica post-apartheid. Rubrica Contemporánea, vol. 5, nº. 9, pp.35-57, 2016.
POLLAK M. Memoria, olvido, silencio. In: POLLAK, M Memoria, olvido, silencio La producción social de las identidades frente a situaciones límite. Edcs, Al Margen: La Plata, 2008, pp.17-32.
ROSS F. Bearing Witness. Women and Truth And Reconciliation Commission In South Africa. London, Pluto Press. 2003.
ROTHBERG, M. Multidirectional Memory and the Implicated Subject. In: PLATE L.; SMELIK, A. (Org.). Performing Memory and art popular, Routledge: New York, 2013. pp.39-58.
ROTHBERG, M. Memory and Implication at the Limits of the Human: A Response to Nathan Snaza. Parallax, vol. 23, nº.4, pp. 512-516, 2017.
SCHNITZLER A.V. Democracy’s Infrastructure: Techno-Politics & Protest after Apartheid. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2006.
SNYMAN, D. Restitution toolkit. Cape Town: Restitution Foundation, 2012.
VECCHIOLI, V. Políticas de la Memoria y Formas de Clasificación Social. ¿Quiénes son las "Víctimas del Terrorismo de Estado" en la Argentina?. In: GROPPO, B.; FLIER, P. (Org). La Imposibilidad del Olvido. Recorridos de la Memoria en Argentina, Chile y Uruguay. Ed. Al Margen. Argentina: La Plata, 2001. pp. 83-102, 2001.
VILLALON, A.M. El cuerpo culpable en el espacio público: de disidencias, traiciones y arrepentimientos en la convivencia vasca. Mana, Rio de Janeiro, vol. 25, nº. 1, pp. 189-219, 2019.
VILLALON, A.M. Construyendo la vasquidad: de estímulos, convivencias y límites lingüísticos. Mana, Rio de Janeiro, vol. 22, nº.2, pp.519-550, 2016.
VILLALON, A.M. Manteniendo el fuego: Mecanismos de construcción de espacios y límites de la vasquidad. 2011. 400 p. Tesis (Doctorado em Antropologia Social) Programa de Pós-Graduação em Antropologia Social, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Museu Nacional, Rio de Janeiro.
WILSON, R. The politics of truth and reconciliation in South Africa. Legitimizing the Post-Apartheid State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.
WIEVIORKA, M. L’émergence des victimes. Sphera publica, nº . 3, pp. 19-38. 2003
ZIMITRI E. Coloured by History, Shaped by Place: new Perspectives on Coloured identities in Cape Town. Social Identities South Africa Series: Cape Town, 2001.
ZULAIKA, J. Violencia Vasca, Metáfora y Sacramento. Madrid: Nerea, 1990.
NOTAS DE PRENSA
Matins: "El País Vasco cura sus heridas"
https://www.24matins.es/topnews/portada/el-pais-vasco-cura-sus-heridas-65868
Las personas torturadas también somos víctimas» https://www.naiz.eus/en/actualidad/noticia/20170311/sortu-la-paz-necesita-que-se-sepa-toda-la-verdad-y-se-reconozca-a-todas-las-victimas
“ETA puso cinco bombas en mi empresa. Nadie llamó para preguntar” https://elpais.com/politica/2017/10/20/actualidad/1508512667_395685.html
“No pude más. Decidí que iba a pagar. Empresarios extorsionados por ETA, hoy en ‘360°’
El programa de ETB-2 ofrecerá el reportaje titulado ‘50 años de olvido’, conducido por Xabier García-Ramsden
El confidencial 12-3-2017: "El 'cáncer' del olvido de los extorsionados por ETA: "No son víctimas de segunda clase". https://www.elconfidencial.com/espana/pais-vasco/2017-03-12/pais-vasco-eta-terrorismo-extorsion-empresarios_1346279/
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish in this journal agree with the following terms:
1. Authors keep the copyrights and allow the journal the right of first publishing, having the paper simultaneously licensed by Creative Commons Attribution License that allows the sharing of the article – copyright recognized - and first publishing in this journal.
2. The journal is allowed to require the copyrights transfer, allowing the article to be used under noncommercial purposes, including the right to send the paper to Free Access or Paid databanks, not assuming the obligation to pass on the value charged from users to the authors.
3. Authors are allowed to take additional contracts separately for nonexclusive distribution of the paper’s version published in this journal (e.g. publishing in institutional repository or as book chapter), recognizing the copyright and first publishing in this journal.